What to Do When Your Paid Social Metrics Look Wrong

Your CPA is creeping up. Your ROAS has dipped. The hook rate on your latest creative is in the bin.

Before you panic, stop.

Not every bad-looking number is a bad situation. Sometimes it’s a blip. Sometimes it’s a lag. And sometimes the problem isn’t where you think it is.

Here’s how to figure out what’s actually going on and what to do about it.

 

A quick reminder before we start

Your ads have one job. Get the right people to your website.

Not all people. The right people. In volume.

But here’s the thing. Your ads stop being responsible the moment someone lands on your site. If the offer isn’t compelling, the landing page is slow, or the checkout is a mess… that’s not an ad problem. That’s a website problem.

Brilliant ads can’t fix a bad website or a weak offer.

Keep that in mind as you read everything below.

Troubleshooting business metrics

These are usually the ones your boss cares most about.

High cost per result

Three things to check.

First, is the offer actually compelling? Not “clear.” Compelling. Would you click on it? If the answer is “maybe,” that’s a no.

Second, if you’re getting clicks but not conversions, the ad isn’t the problem. Go look at the landing page. Load speed, clarity, friction. All of it.

Third, test new creative angles. Sometimes the audience is right but the message is wrong. A different hook can halve your CPA overnight.

Low conversion rate

This is almost never an ads problem. The ad got them there. Something on site is stopping them from buying.

Go detective. Slow page load? Unclear offer? Surprise delivery charges? Complicated checkout? Too many pop-ups?

Step into your customer’s shoes and try to buy your own product. You’ll find the problem in about 90 seconds.

And check by device. Mobile conversion rate is almost always lower than desktop. If 80% of your traffic is mobile and the mobile experience is poor, that’s your answer.

Low average order value

Check what people are actually buying. If your bestsellers are all low-ticket items, your ads might be doing exactly what you asked them to do. Just with the wrong products.

Look at the checkout. Is there a cross-sell or upsell opportunity? “Add X for £5” or “free delivery over £50” is one of the easiest wins in ecommerce.

Bundle products. Create offers that naturally push the basket value up. Don’t just hope people spend more. Engineer it.

Low ROAS

Before you panic… do the maths.

Work out what ROAS you actually need to be profitable based on your margins. Most people chase a ROAS number they’ve plucked from thin air. Once you know your break-even, you might find your “bad” ROAS is actually fine.

Then diagnose the real problem. Low ROAS is a symptom, not a cause. Is engagement low? Is CVR low? Is AOV low? Fix the root, not the headline number.

And remember the attribution gap. Platform ROAS can’t track everything. Check your MER and backend revenue before you make any big decisions. The full picture might look very different.

Low MER

MER is the big picture number. So don’t jump straight to blaming one channel.

If MER is dropping, step back. Look at the whole marketing mix. Has anything else changed? Organic traffic down? Email performance dipped? A campaign ended?

Check whether you’ve recently scaled spend without a proportional increase in revenue. Sometimes MER drops simply because you’re in an investment phase. More spend doesn’t always equal more revenue immediately. There’s a lag.

If MER is low but platform ROAS looks fine, something is leaking. You’re paying for traffic that isn’t converting anywhere. Look at your site, your offer, your pricing. The problem is downstream of the ads, not in them.

Troubleshooting creative metrics

These are usually the ones your ads manager cares most about.

Low hook rate

Your opening isn’t earning attention. You have less than a second. If the first frame looks like an ad, people scroll.

Lead with something unexpected. Emotional. Visually disruptive.

Test different formats. Static images, UGC, talking head, text overlay. Different audiences stop for different things. Don’t assume what works. Let the data tell you.

And look at who the algorithm is showing it to. If your audience is broad and hook rate is low, the creative might not resonate with the people it’s being served to. Sometimes a new angle finds a completely different pocket of people.

Low click-through rate

People are watching but not clicking. The creative is interesting but there’s no reason to act.

Is there a clear call to action? Is the offer obvious? Do they even know where they’re going?

Check the gap between hook rate and CTR. A big gap means the ad entertains but doesn’t persuade. It needs a stronger reason to click. Curiosity, a benefit they can’t ignore, something that makes them think “I need to know more.”

Try moving the CTA earlier. If people drop off halfway through a video, they never see the ask.

High CPM

CPM is what the algorithm charges you for reach. High CPM often means the algorithm doesn’t think your creative is relevant to the audience. Better creative gets rewarded with cheaper delivery.

Check frequency. If CPM is rising alongside frequency, you’ve exhausted the audience. Fresh creative or a broader audience will bring it down.

Check the calendar too. CPM spikes in Q4, around Black Friday, and during major retail events. Sometimes it’s not you. It’s competition for the same eyespace.

When to hold your nerve and when to act

This is the bit most people get wrong.

A metric dips and the instinct is to change something. But knee-jerk reactions cause more damage than the dip itself.

Here’s a simple rule of thumb.

If only platform metrics look shaky, hold steady and check your backend. The platform might be under-reporting. Your actual results could be fine.

If backend metrics are shaky too, act. But diagnose first. Don’t just throw new creative at it or pause everything. Figure out where the breakdown is.

Some specifics:

CPA rising? If it’s been less than 5 days and MER is stable, hold. If it’s been 7+ days and MER is dropping too, investigate.

Creative metrics dipping? If conversions are still steady, hold. If frequency is up and results are down, you need fresh creative.

Just scaled budget? Give it 5-7 days. If there’s still no improvement after a week, something else is going on.

Low conversions? First check it’s not a tracking issue. If you’ve had zero conversions for 48+ hours, that’s when to dig in.

External factors? Bank holidays, payday, seasonality… all of these affect performance. Before you blame the ads, check the calendar.

The golden rule

Never make a change because a number made you feel uncomfortable.

Make a change because the data, across more than one metric, is telling you something consistent.

That’s the difference between reacting and deciding. And your boss will trust you a lot more when you can explain which one you’re doing and why.

Written by Michelle 👋🏼

***********************************

This post is based on content from our Paid Social Confidence Workshop series. If you’d like to join a future session, get in touch.

Want a second pair of eyes on your numbers? Book a 15-minute chat and a brew.